Ozone Generator vs Ionizing Purifier – Side by Side Performance Comparison
One of your main concerns is the quality of the air you inhale when you are at home or at the office. Seeing how pollution is higher than ever these days, both in concern to the outdoor and the indoor environment, it comes as no surprise that the market for air purification devices has thrived and evolved so much. However, with this plentitude comes confusion as you might be left wondering what type of air purifier does a better job. Wonder no more and read the following as here we will cover two of the most prolific types of air cleaning appliances at the moment – the ionizer and the ozone generator. We will analyze their overall performance, discover their good and bad sides, and pin them in opposition to each other to see which the ultimate winner of this “battle” is.
Ozone generating devices and ionizers – General performance description
About ozone generating air purification devices:
Mainly promoted due to the fact that they have an enhanced capability of eliminating odors from enclosed spaces, ozone generating air cleaners are a widely used air cleaning appliance as their role does not end there. As a matter of fact, they tend to eliminate airborne pollutants as well, so their usefulness indoors is incommensurable. Sure, they might output ozone, but this is not an issue if the generator you use does not produce a high amount of this unwanted gas. In terms of performance, they might be easily outweighed by high-end HEPA air purifiers when it comes to air contaminant removal, but they are basically impossible to top in terms of odor removal.
About ionizing air purification devices:
Just like ozone generating devices, ionizing purifiers have the minor downfall of producing ozone when they operate. This is not to say that they are dangerous as the level of output is small enough to not present a health threat when referring to modern ionizers. They are quite similar to traditional air purification devices, utilizing several filtration media to remove harmful airborne pollutants. Where they dramatically differ is that they use ions which are negatively charged to positively charge allergens and dust particles, causing them to drop from the air.
What is the deal with ozone?
As you already most likely know, ozone is a naturally occurring gas which is found in the atmosphere. However, at ground level, it does not occur naturally, meaning that it is created through the means of air pollutants which are expelled by vehicles, among other things. Harmful to the atmosphere as well as humans due to the fact that it makes lungs more predisposed to infections and exacerbates asthma, it is a pollutant you surely want to stay away from. However, this is not to say that any ozone pollution present health threatening exposure as the generally small amount outputted by ionizers as well as ozone generating devices cannot pose a danger to human or animal health.
Ozone generator – Pros and cons
Now that you are familiarized with this air cleaning appliance which uses ozone output to clean the air of harmful pollutants and improve indoor odors, let’s move on to see what are the good and bad sides of utilizing it in an enclosed living space.
- Effective at removing unwanted odors;
- Able to kill germs, viruses, and bacteria lingering in the air – some hospitals even use ozone generating devices for this precise reason;
- Eliminates mold spores with ease;
- Efficient against positively charged air pollutants;
- Generally capable of covering large spaces.
- Does not eliminate the source of the odor;
- Might output a dangerous level of ozone.
Ionizing purifier – Pros and cons
Just like we did with the ozone generator, we will not move on to see what are the pros and cons of utilizing an ionizing purifier. Obviously, perfection is basically impossible to reach, so this appliance is bound to have its own set of flaws as well.
- Generally able to remove even particles as small as 0.01 microns;
- Quite effective at combating unpleasant indoor odors;
- Positively charge dust particles to pick them up before they hit the ground – less vacuuming is required;
- Typically relatively inexpensive when compared to most air purification devices.
- Without the addition of HEPA filtration, it does not tackle pollen all that well;
- If the ozone output is high, it causes irritation to sensitive lungs.
So…What is the better option for air purification?
In terms of air purification performance quality, ozone generating appliances, as well as ionizing purifiers, do a more than decent job, if you go as far as searching the market and buying a quality product, ensuring an even more impressive capability on its part. Furthermore, the two types of devices are quite similar in their performance when it comes to odor removal, so there are no real significant differences between. Basically, to sum it up, if indoor air purification is what you are seeking, regardless of the choice you make, you are bound to notice a significant improvement in air quality.
One last piece of advice before you go:
As long as the ionizing purifier or ozone generator you pick and use outputs a maximum of 0.05 ppm ozone in the air, you are basically safe to use it. To make your life easier, look for one which is UL listed or has an ETL mark as these air cleaning devices have already passed rigorous tests in regards to safety in use for human and animal inhabitants.